iPhone App Directory

Project Ara delayed and more thoughts on modular phones


A little while ago I wrote down some thoughts about modular phones and also about modular operating systems. Then, just a few days ago, Google's Ara got delayed, which I think is interesting. We all know (at least I expect we all know) that hardware is difficult to do, and hardware as complex as something like a modular phone is going to be very difficult.

So, why is Ara going to be delayed? Good question, I think that the official version of the story probably isn't too far from the truth, at least as far as it goes, and it doesn't go far at all. All they've said is that there are more 'iterations' than they expected. That's fair enough, but what does that mean?

I think it probably means that this is a really hard project to get working, and it's introduced way more complications in design than other hardware projects.

Personally I think that they should be talking to people involved in modular synths in order to get a better handle on this stuff. Perhaps it is the hardware, perhaps it is the OS, who really knows, it looks like they're not letting on for now.

I don't think that Apple will be doing anything similar soon, but I'd be interested to know what they think about it and how they might respond.

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Creating anything so new is never easy, quick or cheap... and that road is full of challenges.

Ashley Elsdon said...

Too true. I'm still not convinced on the whole Android thing though.

Unknown said...

For sound is doable.... but in the same way that music & sound were doable for computers in the 90s: Just one thing at a time and with external/off-line Sync. Nothing like the Apple Mac OSX/iOS integrated in the system stuff.
Google is making some steps in the proper direction, but for Google the music making is not key at all so my bet is that it will be more or less like now (with some improvements, for quite a long time.
Anyway, Android is the only alternative by now.... unless Apple starts licesing iOS to third parties (and that is not coming anytime soon or at all).